Horse racing doesn’t handle expectations well. The problem from a sporting perspective is clear — horses don’t compete with the excitement of fans in mind. In many years, a nondescript claiming race at Monmouth may provide more of a thrill to fans than the Kentucky Derby. This puts the Breeders’ Cup, and specifically the Classic, in an awkward position as the culminating event of the season.
Sometimes, the race delivers. The two Derby winners hit the wire together when Ferdinand beat Alysheba in ’88. Cigar had the heart of a champion in ’96 but couldn’t repeat against giant killer Alphabet Soup. Awesome Again beat one of the best fields ever assembled on dirt in ’98. Zenyatta pulled off the unbelievable in ’09. When the race lives up to the hype, there’s nothing better.